Money Week: Latin America’s new best friends
Money Week: Latin America’s new best friends
What have Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Shinzo Abe got in common?
Well, they’re all old enough to remember the moon landings.
They’re also the leaders of some of the most powerful countries in the world.
And this month, they are all either in the middle of – or have just finished conducting – strategic tours of Latin America.
For New World readers these visits from the presidents of Russia, China and Japan are a positive development. They show that the rest of the world is starting to take Latin America seriously, which should lead to more investment pouring into the region. And that’s great for us.
Let’s look at China first.
The new home for Chinese investment
I’ve been all over Latin America this year, and everywhere I’ve gone I’ve seen increasing signs of Chinese investment. As I’ve sat in reception, waiting to interview government ministers or company CEOs, more often than not there’s been a Chinese delegation waiting along with me.
I’ve also noticed that when I’m asking how these policymakers or businesspeople plan to fund their ambitious plans, their hopes for financing from the Far East normally come into the conversation.
Ties between China and Latin America have been strengthening over the last few years to the point where China has overtaken the US as the main trading partner for many Latin American countries, including Brazil.
The driving force behind Latin America’s exports to China is – unsurprisingly – commodities. China’s economic growth has been sustained by remarkably high levels of investment on fixed assets such as roads, airports and housing. That has required enormous amounts of copper, oil and iron ore, which Latin America has in abundance.
The rising living standards and subsequent growing bellies of China’s emerging classes has also led to an increased demand for soy beans, one of Latin America’s top exports to China.
Meanwhile, Latin America’s decade of prosperity made it an increasingly important market for Chinese manufactures – especially when the 2008 financial crisis hit demand in the developed world.
As for the rising foreign direct investment (FDI) and government loans, that is part of a wider trend where a richer China is looking to make strategic investments outside its borders. Unsurprisingly the majority of Chinese investment in Latin America is concentrated on agriculture, mining and energy products.
But are these developments as beneficial as they appear?
China invades Latin American TV
Of course, there are a number of legitimate concerns about increased trade with China.
Firstly, trade is not equal. Latin America is running a $10bn trade deficit with China. And this inequality is somewhat inherent in the trading relationship, because the bulk of Latin American exports to China are made up of oil, soy, iron ore and copper. In return, China sells Latin America a diversified basked of manufactured goods, which makes it less vulnerable to a downswing in any one sector.
And then there’s the political element. In Ecuador, I was amazed to see people watching dubbed versions of Chinese soap operas. But creating Spanish language versions of its state-controlled TV and websites is just one of the ways China is projecting ‘soft power’ into Latin America. Throughout the region, it’s also opened 32 ‘Confucius Institutes’ – public institutions associated with the Chinese government.
All that may sound pretty harmless. But other moves, such as the decision to fund a $40bn rival to the US-built Panama Canal, and the offers of military equipment, expertise and training with Colombia, Chile, Mexico and Brazil are a lot more significant.
But I’m still pretty optimistic.
It’s true that Latin America’s exports to China are pretty concentrated, but at the very least the rise of China has helped the region diversify its export markets away from overdependence on Europe and the US.
And it’s not like this is a closely guarded secret. I’ve spoken to government ministers across the region about this and they are all well aware that they need to develop other sectors of the economy. And to be fair, in places such as Chile, Peru and Colombia they have been trying to do this for a while now.
As for the political reasons, China could hardly do worse than the US, UK, Spain or France, who all played their part in financing wars in the region over the centuries.
So will Russia and Japan be looking to emulate China’s increased role in the region?
A chance to recover lost opportunities
Since the collapse of the USSR, the Russian Federation has not really paid Latin America much attention. But now Putin is looking to amend that. Agreements on nuclear energy and shale oil were signed in Argentina, and Putin wrote off 90% of Cuba’s historic debt with the Soviet Union and pledged to invest the remainder in much-needed infrastructure projects in the island.
For Russia, it’s a chance to “recover lost opportunities”, said Putin, speaking in Havana.
Shinzo Abe’s trip is going on as I write this, so we’re not sure what deals have been made yet. But with nuclear energy taking a hit from Fukushima it’s clear that Japan will have to rely on a lot more fossil fuels for the medium term. Sitting across the Pacific, commodity-rich Latin America would seem a perfect trading partner. And like China, Japan is eager to make some money from Latin America’s burgeoning infrastructure programmes.
So what’s the benefit for us?
Now, all of these grand geopolitical moves are interesting to watch, but no doubt you’ll want to know how they benefit small, private UK-based investors like us.
Well on one level, they help to boost asset prices in the region.
For example, I was in Peru recently where all the talk in the mining sector was about Chinese consortium MMG’s plan to buy the huge Las Bambas copper mine from Glencore for $6bn. In recent years, Latin American mines, fisheries, farmland, and oil plays have all been snapped up in billion-dollar deals by Chinese firms. And I spoke to plenty of businesspeople that were trying to create projects of enough size and scale to attract cash-rich Chinese buyers.
I’ve been cagey about investing in too many commodity plays as prices have been falling. But the energy and farming stocks that I have picked will benefit from increased demand for their assets.
The other theme that should benefit is Latin American infrastructure. This is one of my favourite investment stories, and I have tipped a host of firms that should benefit from the many projects planned in Latin America. For example, China will provide $4.4bn for the building of two new hydroelectric dams in Santa Cruz province, and part-finance the construction of Argentina’s fourth nuclear power plant.